Ellery Care data study
The Texas nursing home transparency scorecard
A high star rating is reassuring, and families lean on it. But the headline number is a blend, and it can sit on top of a serious safety record it never shows you. We checked every highly-rated Texas home against the harder facts in its federal file.
Method v1.0 · CMS snapshot 2026-09-05 · dataset 4pq5-n9py · released under CC BY 4.0
Of the 338 Texas nursing homes rated four or five stars overall, 147, about 43%, carry at least one serious red flag in their government record: a federal abuse warning, an immediate-jeopardy inspection finding, a large fine, or a top-tier rate of drugging, falls, or bedsores. Even among five-star homes, 50 of 133 carry one. This is the gap between the number that reassures and the record underneath. The 31 homes below carry two or more flags at once.
Use this data
Journalists, researchers, and educators may cite these findings with a link to this study. Data comes from CMS Care Compare and related federal datasets. Snapshot: 2026-09-05. The five largest metros are broken out below; for another city, county, chain, or facility cut, email [email protected]. Downloads, the data dictionary, and citation formats are on the data & press resources page.
Last updated 2026-09-05 from the CMS snapshot. Spot an error? Email [email protected] and we will correct it and note the change.
| # | Facility | City | Rating | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Brixton At Horseshoe Bay | Horseshoe Bay | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyFine of $50k+High serious-fall rateHigh bedsore rate |
| 2 | Avir At Pittsburg | Pittsburg | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyFine of $50k+High bedsore rate |
| 3 | Discovery Village At Southlake | Southlake | ★★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh serious-fall rateHigh bedsore rate |
| 4 | Park Manor Of Humble | Humble | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyFine of $50k+ |
| 5 | Ware Memorial Care Center | Amarillo | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyFine of $50k+ |
| 6 | Richmond Health Care Center | Richmond | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyFine of $50k+ |
| 7 | Lindan Park Care Center LP | Richardson | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyFine of $50k+ |
| 8 | Heritage Trails Nursing And Rehabilitation Center | Cleburne | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyFine of $50k+ |
| 9 | Holiday Hill INC | Coleman | ★★★★ | Fine of $50k+High bedsore rate |
| 10 | Crestview Healthcare Residence | Waco | ★★★★ | Fine of $50k+Heavy antipsychotic use |
| 11 | College Park Rehabilitation And Care Center | Weatherford | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 12 | Presbyterian Village North Special Care Ctr | Dallas | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 13 | Seven Acres Jewish Senior Care Services | Houston | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 14 | The Waterton Healthcare & Rehabilitation | Tyler | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh serious-fall rate |
| 15 | Brookdale Trinity Towers | Corpus Christi | ★★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh serious-fall rate |
| 16 | Prestonwood Rehabilitation & Nursing Center | Plano | ★★★★ | Abuse warningImmediate jeopardy |
| 17 | Ffiii Houston Snf Tenant LLC | Houston | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 18 | Tuscany Village | Pearland | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 19 | Carrara | Plano | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 20 | Avir At Center | Center | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh serious-fall rate |
| 21 | Mcallen Transitional Care Center | Mcallen | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 22 | Pine Grove Nursing Center | Center | ★★★★★ | High serious-fall rateHigh bedsore rate |
| 23 | Monument Rehabilitation And Nursing Center | La Grange | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh serious-fall rate |
| 24 | Rose Haven Retreat | Atlanta | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHeavy antipsychotic use |
| 25 | Crown Point Health Suites | Lubbock | ★★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 26 | Avir At Courtyard | Houston | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 27 | Avir At Paris | Paris | ★★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 28 | St. Francis Nursing Home | San Antonio | ★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
| 29 | Renaissance Rehabilitation And Healthcare Center | Italy | ★★★★★ | Heavy antipsychotic useHigh serious-fall rate |
| 30 | Shinnery Oaks Community | Denver City | ★★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh serious-fall rate |
| 31 | S.P.J.S.T. Rest Home No 2 | Needville | ★★★★★ | Immediate jeopardyHigh bedsore rate |
The gap, by metro
The same pattern shows up locally. In each of Texas's five largest metros, this is how many four- and five-star homes carry at least one serious red flag in their federal record.
| Metro | 4-5 star homes | Carry a red flag | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Houston | 16 | 3 | See the homes → |
| Dallas | 7 | 1 | See the homes → |
| San Antonio | 13 | 1 | See the homes → |
| Austin | 5 | 0 | See the homes → |
| Fort Worth | 4 | 0 | See the homes → |
Same CMS snapshot (2026-09-05) and the same red-flag definition as the statewide finding above. Need another city, county, or chain cut? Email [email protected].
Which red flags show up most
Across the 147 flagged homes, this is how often each marker appears. Immediate-jeopardy findings drive the list; outright abuse warnings are rarest.
- Immediate jeopardy92
- High serious-fall rate38
- High bedsore rate32
- Fine of $50k+10
- Heavy antipsychotic use9
- Abuse warning1
Homes can carry more than one marker, so these counts sum to more than 147.
What each red flag means
- Abuse warning
- Carries the federal abuse-warning icon on CMS Care Compare.
- Immediate jeopardy
- Cited for at least one immediate-jeopardy deficiency, the most serious category, in recent inspection cycles.
- Fine of $50k+
- Has paid $50,000 or more in federal fines in roughly the last three years.
- Heavy antipsychotic use
- Gives antipsychotic drugs to a quarter or more of its long-stay residents.
- High serious-fall rate
- Serious-fall rate at least double the Texas median.
- High bedsore rate
- Pressure-ulcer (bedsore) rate at least double the Texas median.
Why this matters
Star ratings are meant to help, and mostly they do. The problem is what a single number hides. Around the country, families and reporters keep finding the same thing: official sources can make a home look clean while the underlying records tell a harder story. A Tennessee investigation in 2026 found the state showing homes as having no disciplinary action even when they carried six-figure federal fines. When the reassuring surface and the real record disagree, a family that stops at the surface can make the wrong call.
That is the whole reason we exist. We take no money from any facility, so we have no reason to smooth over an unfavorable record. This scorecard puts the star rating next to the flags in the same view, so you can see both at once.
What to do with this
A flag is a reason to look closer, not proof a home is bad. Some of these are strong homes that had a serious finding and corrected it. Look up the specific home, read its inspection findings and fines, and if it carries a flag, ask the staff directly what happened and what changed. The goal is to walk in informed rather than reassured by a number alone.
How we built this
We started with every Texas home CMS rates four or five stars overall (338 homes) and checked each against six serious markers in its federal record: a federal abuse-warning icon, an immediate-jeopardy deficiency in recent inspection cycles, $50,000 or more in federal fines, antipsychotic use in a quarter or more of long-stay residents, and serious-fall or pressure-ulcer rates at least double the Texas median. The three rate-based markers only count for homes with at least 25 residents, so a small facility's percentage cannot trip them. The table shows homes carrying two or more flags at once. Every figure comes from CMS. Full details on our methodology page.
Common questions
Does a 5-star nursing home rating mean a home is safe?
Not on its own. The CMS overall star rating is a useful starting point, but it is a blended score that can sit on top of a serious problem. Of the 133 five-star homes in Texas, 50 carry at least one serious red flag in their federal record. Always read the specific record, not just the stars.
What counts as a serious red flag in this scorecard?
A federal abuse-warning icon, an immediate-jeopardy inspection finding, a fine of $50,000 or more, antipsychotic use in a quarter or more of long-stay residents, or a serious-fall or pressure-ulcer rate at least double the Texas median. Every one is a factual government record, not our opinion.
How should I use this when choosing a home?
Do not stop at the star rating. Look up the specific home, read its inspection findings and fines, and if it carries a flag, ask the staff about it directly and how they fixed it. A single corrected finding is not automatically disqualifying, but you deserve to know it is there.
Checking on a specific home?
Every Texas nursing home report card shows the star rating next to the record underneath it: staffing, inspection findings, fines, drug use, and preventable-harm rates, with plain-English context.
Correction log
No corrections recorded. If a figure here is wrong, email [email protected] and we will fix it and log the change here, with the date and what moved.
Methodology & how to cite
Highly-rated Texas nursing homes cross-checked against their CMS fines, abuse flags, and health-deficiency records. Data as of 2026-09-05. Full method and sources are on our methodology page.
Cite this analysis (APA):
Ellery Care Research Team. (2026). Texas Nursing Home Transparency Scorecard (2026). Ellery Care. https://ellerycare.com/studies/texas-nursing-home-transparency-scorecard/
Journalists and researchers are welcome to cite these figures with a link back. Downloads, the data dictionary, and citation formats for every study are on our data & press resources page. For a custom data pull or a quote, contact [email protected].
Source: CMS Care Compare (Nursing Homes), dataset 4pq5-n9py, CMS MDS Quality Measures, and CMS Health Deficiencies, retrieved 2026-09-05. Ellery Care accepts no payment from any facility and is not affiliated with CMS. A red flag is a factual federal record, not an allegation of current wrongdoing. Educational information, not medical advice. Related: the most-fined nursing homes in Texas.